By ALMA B. SINUMLAG Mary Lou Marigza

APARRI, Cagayan — Community dialogues in magnetite mining affected communities expressed strong opposition to foreign companies mining the Rio Grande de Cagayan and the beaches of the Babuyan channel.

MINING. Magnetite mining in Punta Aparri. Photo courtesy of KADUAMI
A documentation mission organized by Alyansa ng mga Mamamayan Laban sa Dayuhang Kontrol na Pagmimina last August 15-19 in the towns of Camalaniugan and Aparri noted the opposition of the people to foreign mining in their barangays. The documentation mission was participated in by Amihan (women peasant organization in Cagayan), KADUAMI (Katinnulong Daguiti Umili iti Amianan), Kagimongan (peasant organization) and Rural Missionaries of the Philippines.

In Allacapan, manganese mining is being done. The people have expressed alarm over the eroding riverbanks that caused scores of houses to be destroyed as well as infrastructures that were washed down the river during strong typhoons. Mothers expressed concern over their children’s health as they breath in the dust blown into thhe atmosphere by the black sand mining operations.

People of Sapping and Dugo in Camalaniugan recounted that prior to the entry of magnetite mining by foreigners who were “kusipet ti matada” (chinky eyed), river bank erosion was a meter or so. But after the extraction activities, the communities even in higher grounds now experience flooding and the river is eating up the riverbanks several meters at a time inland. The Rio Grande de Cagayan is now a menace instead of an aid to agriculture and livelihood.

Mothers recounted that a radio is a must during the typhoon season and they always listen to weather bulletins to prepare for flooding. They said that even if no storm signal is raised over Cagayan if the rains are strong over Magat dam and Chico river, they have always evacuated as the dam releases water and Chico river overflows. They said the worst flooding they experienced was during the Typhoons Ondoy, Pepeng and Juan where they were forced to live in their banca (Canoe) as water was slow to subside.

Fisherfolks whose livelihood depend on the river recount that the fish stock is now scarce. They attribute this to the murkiness of the water after the mining operations, so the fish migrate upstream where the waters are clearer. “Nalibeg ngaminen ti danum,” they lament, so the fishes have no more breeding and feeding areas.

They recount stories of catching plentiful delectable ipon that was once abundant in the river. Or the magical ludong that is a gift of the Cagayan river to the people of the valley. They hardly see a ludong anymore.

Merci, a former barangay official of Dugo, narrated how the people clapped when a barge filled with magnetite of the “kusipet ti matada” grounded in a shallow part of the river. “Gungguna yo a ta taktakawen yo ti darat mi!” (“Serves you right for you are stealing our sands”) the people shouted as the men on the barge were calling for aid. They celebrated the victory of the people of Jurisdiction, Lal-lo who evicted the boats and barges getting magnetite sand for illegally mining without permit.

When asked if the mining company or the local government unit informed them of the mining, they said no consultation happened. The officials had informed them that the river will be dredged but they were surprised when the boats and barges kept coming for more black sand. Many of them told the documentation team, “Basta lattan nga immay dagiti barko ken barge da. Agsubli-subli. No mapunno da, agsubli da manen.” (“The big boats and barges just appeared. They fill the barges with black sand, leave, then come back.”)

Many of the interviewees were once living in Felipe Tuzon across the river that evacuated to the centro and are now renting the lots where their houses stand from private individuals who were kind enough to provide them the space. At daytime, some of them go back to tend the fields that were not washed out in Felipe Tuzon to augment fishing that has now become scarce.

In Sapping, there is an ongoing riverbank rehabilitation project costing some P42 million for a 100 meter embankment. Lamented a mother, “If only that money were used to build schools and roads, we would be happier.”

The people of Punta and Bisagu in Aparri face the same problems on a magnified scale since the sea and the river flood them. The fisherfolks reported the same problem of riverbank erosion and reduced fish catch. Most of them have ready floaters in case of flood. Typhoon Juan soaked the marshy homeland of the people of Bisagu for more than a week.

Some of them evacuated to as far as Bukuig, Allacapan since the water rose so high and they could not cross Cagayan River. They said their evacuation plans involved the women and children going first and the men staying behind to care for the animals that could not be evacuated and stay on their roofs. If the roofs are breached, then the men follow with the animals in the boats. This happened during Typhoon Pepeng and Juan.

The older people narrated that the elementary school they went to was about a kilometer to the river that was eaten up by the rising waters and erosion. Now the school is built deeper inside the barrio but even then the floodwaters still reach it up to the windows. A sandbank now exists in the mouth of the Rio Grande de Cagayan where they gather firewood washed by the river during floods. They fear the coming of the next storm and the next flood since they said the waters keep rising each year.

Shellfish that used to abound in the banks are now gone. They recounted getting kaggo, unnuk and many more from the sand but now these can hardly be found. Like in Camalaniugan, sometimes they take a day off from fishing since they are just wasting their money for gasoline for a measly two kilos catch unlike five years ago when they used to fish everyday and their boats were loaded.

In Punta, the former barangay officials told the team that a meeting by local officials was called to inform the people that a canned goods factory was going to be built in Punta. Much to their surprise no factory was built instead a steady flow of barges getting black sand is what they witnessed. The area remains an informal settlers abode with the threat of demolition always hanging over them. The succession of elected officials promised to give them relocation areas but since it is a vote-rich place they have remained, with eviction any time looming.

The magnetite mining site in Punta does not bear any signage. But the compound houses four backhoes working 24/7, several dump trucks filled with black sand, mounds and mounds of black sand and “reject” as the people call them, separator machines and a drilling machine that shakes the houses of the people when operating. The people in the vicinity could not open their doors and windows since the wind will blow the dust inside their homes. They said the last ship left about two weeks before the documentation team arrived.

They described the ships as having suction hoses reaching the bottom of the river and spewing the “rejects” through another pipe (agsusop diay maysa, agpuswak ti reject diay maysa) while the barges that have earlier been filled continue to load the ships. As soon as the ships are full, they leave Aparri to ports unknown while the barges stay to fill up.

The magnetite mining from the ships or from the beach has been going on since 2008. The mining site is just moved from barrio to barrio. The people have expressed alarm at the damage the mining is causing but local officials seem deaf to their pleas.

A minor victory was achieved by the people of Gonzaga, Cagayan when the Department of Environment and Natural Resources issued a suspension of operations order against Lian Xing Phils. Stone Carving Co. Corp. and Huaxia Mining and Trading Corporation last April 29, 2011 for violating their contracts on magnetite mining. This, even as some leaders were charged with libel for airing the magnetite mining occuring in their areas.

The people on the river and the sea in Cagayan affected by magnetite mining continue with their opposition as they seek all means possible to preserve their fragile marine environment. #

2 thoughts on “Cagayan folk oppose magnetite mining

  1. Firstly, I have been commenting on various items posted through Kaduama over the years. It is a reasonably accurate account of the situation found and actually ongoing as I write, in a lot of the local coastal areas. I am a practicing Roman Catholic, and very PRO mining. A lot of the true and actual facts are not presented in a correct manner. Villagers are lead by the nose by the church, so a lot of the actual facts are very blured.
    Mining is good for the Philippines and it is impossible to stop progress, now or into the future. Where it all falls down is the ZERO control over the mining companies, and their greed in
    damaging the environment. There needs to be a strong management of the mining equipment and especially the methods used by these unscruplous carpet baggers.
    In the above blog you will notice the sentence “WASTE SAND OVER THE BACK” This is totally unacceptable as it surely kills all shell fish, marine grasses, and baby fish. This inturn kills the river as it does not produce oxygen. Mining can be a help or a killer. Sand dredging can and must be done by total dredging. This means all dredged materials must be pumped on land and processed. NO DUMPING OF WASTE BACK TO THE RIVER.


    1. Thanks again for your comment. Mining in the Philippines has been done without regard to the protection of the environment and the food habitat of the people. This is indeed a sad state of affairs.

      Like you, we do believe that mining can propel developement and progress. But mining should have the consent of the people, the resources gathered should be used for the benefit of the people and the economy and a program for rehabilitation must be put in place.

      Again, keep your comments coming. We welcome the discourse. Thank you.

      For, by and with the people, Kaduami

      (Regional Development Center – Northern Luzon) Kaduami, Inc.- Katinnulong Daguiti Umili iti Amianan People’s Partner in Northern Luzon Tel No: (063) (74) 446-2100 Office Address: #176 Bengao Road, Bakakeng Central, Baguio City 2600 Philippines Mailing Address: P.O. Box 1969, Baguio City 2600, Philippines





Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s